To Hack or Not To Hack | Collagen Supplements
Do they truly turn back the clock—or are we being sold a beauty dream?
Welcome back to our To Hack or Not to Hack series, where I cut through the wellness noise and unpack the science behind trending health products. This week, I’m diving into collagen supplements—a booming industry often marketed as the secret to youthful skin, flexible joints, and stronger hair and nails.
But do these powdered promises actually deliver results worth the hype—or the price? Let's break it down.
🧬 What Is Collagen, and Why Is Everyone Talking About It?
Collagen is the most abundant protein in the human body, accounting for approximately 30% of its total protein content. It serves as a primary structural component in connective tissues, including skin, bones, tendons, ligaments, and cartilage. Collagen's unique triple-helix structure provides strength and elasticity, essential for maintaining the integrity and function of various bodily systems.
Starting in the mid-20s, the body's natural collagen production begins to decline at a rate of about 1% per year . This decrease accelerates significantly after menopause in women and generally after age 60 in both sexes . The reduction in collagen synthesis is attributed to both intrinsic aging processes and extrinsic factors such as UV exposure, smoking, and poor nutrition.
The decline in collagen leads to several physiological changes, including:
Skin Aging: Loss of skin elasticity, increased wrinkles, and dryness.
Joint Degeneration: Reduced cartilage integrity, leading to joint stiffness and discomfort.
Bone Density Reduction: Decreased bone strength, increasing the risk of fractures.
The Rise of Collagen Supplements
The use of collagen in health and beauty products dates back to the 1980s and 1990s, primarily in topical formulations aimed at reducing signs of aging . However, the concept of ingestible collagen gained significant traction in the early 2000s, with supplements marketed for skin health, joint support, and overall vitality.
The global collagen supplement market has experienced substantial growth, valued at $1.99 billion in 2021 and projected to reach $2.88 billion by 2028 . This surge is driven by increasing consumer awareness of health and wellness, as well as the aging population's desire to maintain youthful appearance and mobility.
The Social Media and Influencer Impact
The popularity of collagen supplements has been amplified by social media platforms, where influencers and celebrities share their wellness routines. Products like collagen powders, gummies, and drinks are frequently featured in "what's in my bag" videos and daily health regimens . This visibility has contributed to collagen's transformation from a niche product to a mainstream health supplement.
Notable figures endorsing collagen supplements have validated their use in the eyes of consumers, leading to widespread adoption across various demographics. The trend has also spurred the development of diverse collagen-infused products, including protein bars, teas, and skincare items.
Collagen Sourcing
With collagen now firmly planted in the wellness spotlight — thanks to aging concerns, science-backed claims, and a healthy dose of influencer endorsement — the question naturally becomes: where does all this supplemental collagen actually come from? Whether it’s in your morning coffee, smoothie packet, or glowing Instagram story, most of the collagen on the market is derived from animal sources, and understanding how it's made can help you decide if it's truly right for your body — and your values.
The most common sources include:
Bovine (cow): High in Type I and III collagen—key for skin and bones.
Marine (fish): Popular for its higher bioavailability and sustainability.
Porcine (pig): Similar in structure to human collagen, often used in medical settings.
Most products are hydrolyzed (broken down into collagen peptides) to enhance absorption.
What the Research Actually Says
For all the buzz around collagen powders and peptides, what does the science actually say when we look past the marketing? While early studies show some potential benefits — especially for skin hydration and joint comfort — the research is still young, and often industry-funded. That doesn’t make it useless, but it does mean we need to interpret the data with a discerning eye. Here's what we know:
Skin Health: Several small studies suggest collagen peptides can improve skin elasticity, hydration, and density when taken consistently over several weeks. But many of these studies are funded by supplement manufacturers.
Joint & Bone Support: There's modest evidence that collagen may help reduce joint pain in people with osteoarthritis and support bone mineral density in postmenopausal women.
Muscle Mass: One study showed increased muscle mass and strength in older adults when collagen was combined with resistance training.
Pros and Cons of Supplementing
✅ The Potential Pros:
May support skin hydration and firmness
Can reduce joint discomfort in aging adults
Easy to incorporate into daily routines (e.g., in smoothies or coffee)
⚠️ The Real Cons:
Digestion limits its promise: Collagen is broken down into amino acids in the stomach—your body may use them however it sees fit, not necessarily for skin or joint repair.
Not vegan/vegetarian friendly: All collagen supplements come from animals.
Quality concerns: Supplements are not FDA-approved and may contain contaminants if not third-party tested.
Cost: For uncertain benefit, it’s a pricey habit.
Can You Boost Collagen Without a Supplement?
Yes—and I’d argue this is the more sustainable, nutrient-dense route. Collagen production relies on a synergy of nutrients. Here’s how to support it naturally:
Eat Vitamin C-rich foods (like citrus, strawberries, bell peppers): essential for collagen synthesis.
Get enough protein: especially glycine and proline (found in chicken skin, egg whites, and bone broth).
Protect your skin: UV rays and smoking are collagen killers.
Stay hydrated and minimize excess sugar, which damages collagen through glycation.
Regulation and Transparency
In the U.S., collagen supplements are regulated as dietary supplements, not medications. That means no mandatory safety or efficacy testing before hitting shelves. Unless a brand is third-party tested, there's no guarantee you’re getting what’s on the label.
TO HACK OR NOT TO HACK?
✔️ Not to Hack
Collagen supplements may offer mild benefits for some—but for the average person, especially when paired with a high price tag, unclear absorption, and inconsistent research, they don’t live up to the promise.
My recommendation? Skip the scoop. Focus instead on a nourishing, whole-food diet that naturally supports collagen production. Your skin, joints, and wallet will thank you.
Coming Up Next: Face Icing — Legit Glow or Just a Cold Trend?
In our next To Hack or Not to Hack deep dive, we’re breaking down face icing. This chilly skincare ritual promises reduced puffiness, tighter pores, and a radiant glow. But is it just frosty fluff or backed by science? I’ll unpack the truth so you don’t have to.
Join the Vango Wellness Community!
💌 Subscribe to my newsletter for more wellness tips.
📲 Follow me on Instagram for daily motivation.
🎯 Book a FREE coaching consultation to start your personalized wellness journey.
🛒 Purchase the Supermarket Guide to help you make the right choices when grocery shopping.
Your daily rituals add up. Choose them wisely.